Israel’s Opposition Moves Toward Coalition Talks, but Can Eisenkot Actually Replace Netanyahu?
Yisrael Beiteinu leader Avigdor Lieberman has backed Gadi Eisenkot to form a government, while opposition parties begin coalition talks. No new government is assured; the numbers and red lines remain difficult.
A challenge to Netanyahu, not yet a change of government
Israeli opposition parties have begun coalition negotiations and agreed to support Gadi Eisenkot as the candidate to form the next government. Avigdor Lieberman, leader of Yisrael Beiteinu, has said he will recommend Eisenkot and will not serve in a government led by Benjamin Netanyahu. The developments strengthen the opposition’s attempt to end Netanyahu’s decade-long dominance, but they do not make Eisenkot prime minister yet.
The election left neither the Netanyahu bloc nor the opposition with a clear majority. Reports have described a 120-seat Knesset divided among a Likud-led bloc, an opposition bloc and Arab parties. The path to a coalition depends on whether parties can agree on partners and policy, not simply on which leader gets the most endorsements.
The coalition arithmetic is complicated
Lieberman has publicly rejected a government with Netanyahu and has expressed openness to a government that includes ultra-Orthodox parties, though his past positions on military service exemptions create tension. Several opposition leaders have also resisted relying on Arab parties, even if Arab lawmakers’ support or abstention could be arithmetically decisive.
Channel 12 reported that opposition leaders agreed to open coalition talks and coordinate parliamentary strategy. That is different from a signed coalition agreement. The parties still need to agree on cabinet posts, military service policy, judicial questions, budget priorities and the role of Arab parties.
Netanyahu’s allies have accused the opposition of relying on parties they label unacceptable, while the opposition argues that it can assemble a stable government. Those are political claims; the decisive test will be whether a majority can be presented to the president and survive a confidence vote.
The ultra-Orthodox question is a major obstacle because military-service exemptions divide potential partners. Lieberman has advocated broader service, while Haredi parties seek to preserve exemptions. Arab parties could be numerically important, yet several opposition leaders reject bringing them into a coalition. These incompatible positions mean the reported talks are not a deal. A majority must be assembled and survive a confidence vote before power changes hands.
Some reports have described Lieberman as willing to work with ultra-Orthodox parties, while his public statements and past policy positions leave conditions unclear. That uncertainty makes the word “agreed” too strong unless a signed coalition arrangement is made public. The opposition’s common objective—replacing Netanyahu—may help them negotiate initially, but policy disputes over religion, military service and Arab representation can quickly test that alliance. Political momentum is real; the prime ministership is not yet decided.
Could Eisenkot bridge the divisions among parties whose common ground is largely opposition to Netanyahu? Or might the coalition talks collapse and force another election? The next steps, not the headlines, will determine whether power changes hands.